Quite simple really – don’t.
Give this one a miss. Let Pokémon Go... well, go.
Is that it?
Indeed. Just let the students have their fun catching imaginary beasts in their leisure time.
Oh, I see. We’ve got ourselves a hater here...
No, you haven’t. My son loves the game. I’ve played a little bit myself and found it amusing (never really been into Pokémon that much, even the first time round but I’ve nothing against the game itself).
But I thought you were into all this GBL stuff...
I am... but that’s kind of the point. I’ve seen a lot of excitement and enthusiastic ideas for using the game but they are all ‘classic’ language learning activities – describe the monsters, describe the location, compare your avatars... I’m more into games that prompt discussion (interactive fiction titles like Her Story, for instance), promote critical thinking (think simple puzzle apps like Can You Escape?), encourage exploration and experimentation (such as survival titles like The Long Dark) and/or facilitate creativity and productivity (Minecraft, what else?)
Hang on – I’ve just taken a quick look back through your blog and you have lesson plans on here about describing avatars and ideas about gap-fill walkthroughs.
I do, and that’s where my thinking began a few years ago. I think it’s only natural to look at familiar activities and try to adapt them to a different medium. Speculation and prediction activities are usually among the first we try out, then descriptions, and then things like writing narratives based on the game or using a level guide as a reading text. There’s nothing wrong with doing that of course but it soon becomes seen by the students for what it is – more of the same kind of tasks they do with their course books.
So, these augmented reality geo-location games are not going to add much to my students’ learning then.
There is actually great potential in this area. AR apps and geo-location triggers create opportunities to learn in context by taking the classroom with you rather than trying to bring the outside world in (Urban Chronicles, a project by Paul Driver, is a prime example of how getting students to interact with input ‘on location’ can be an enriching learning experience...) This involves carefully constructed and targeted multi-modal access to information and ideas, however, not so much capturing animated objects and then describing them to a partner.
Hmm, should I just ignore it when my students start talking about the game then?
If your students want to talk about it, by all means let them. Just approach it in the same way you would anything else happening in the world that they want to talk about – ask them about it, let them speak and then build on it dogme-style if you wish or move on.
See this great mini-plan from Phil Wade for an idea of how you could frame such a discussion:
Really? What about Minecraft then?
Of course it is...
Seriously – that is, yes, an immensely popular game but it has developed in such a way that it has opened up all sorts of possibilities for creation and creativity. It can be used to support a multitude of subjects, to teach things, to learn things, to make projects, to collaborate, to realise ideas... Even if your students are expert players, there are still things they can discover about the game and bigger idea they can think about through playing it. Pokémon Go simply isn’t that kind of game. It may develop into something like that in the future – we’ll just have to wait and see.
Well, you still tricked me into coming here by promising lesson ideas...
Fair enough. Plenty of ideas and have been shared here. They are worth checking out but if you are thinking about getting into game-based learning for more than a lesson or two, I suggest you start looking beyond language points and key vocabulary. Anyway, please see:
- 9 Fun Ways to Practice English with Pokémon GO - Shelly Terrell should always be your first stop for lesson ideas.
- Hijacking Pokémon GO for some learning - Chia Suan Chong champions the cause for taking advantage of what's popular with learners for some classroom action and shares some ideas (but presents the other side of the debate as well).
- 15 ways you could use Pokémon GO to teach English - James Prior has written a couple of posts on the app, though I still think that just because you could doesn't mean you should...